Our Work

"Bryna Godar of the University of Wisconsin explains how Minnesota could prosecute federal law enforcement on state charges."

"State officials vow their own investigation, setting up a potential legal clash with federal officials."

Senior Editor Anna Bower spoke with Carolyn Shapiro, co-director of Chicago-Kent College of Law's Institute on the Supreme Court, and Bryna Godar, a Staff Attorney with the State Democracy Research Initiative at the University of Wisconsin Law School. The discussion covered the state of Minnesota’s jurisdiction to criminally investigate Jonathan Ross, the ICE official who reportedly shot and killed Renee Nicole Good on Jan. 7. The conversation also covered obstacles state prosecutors might face in pursuing a potential prosecution and the likelihood that Ross could raise what’s known as "Supremacy Clause immunity."

As part of President Trump’s efforts to expand federal control over the country’s historically state-run election infrastructure, the U.S. Department of Justice has demanded copies of states’ complete voter registration lists, including voters’ highly sensitive data like birthdates, partial Social Security numbers, and driver’s license numbers. The Justice Department has filed federal lawsuits against 30 states (so far) and Washington, D.C., seeking orders compelling these jurisdictions to turn over their data. This tracker monitors the Justice Department’s lawsuits.

"There is a doctrine called supremacy clause immunity that prohibits state officials from prosecuting federal officers when they’re reasonably acting in their official capacity. It’s not absolute immunity like the administration claims, but it’s still a high hurdle for any prosecution to overcome.” (References SDRI Research).

"States have broad power to regulate within their borders unless the U.S. Constitution bars it, but many of these laws raise novel issues that courts will have to sort out, said Harrison Stark, senior counsel with the State Democracy Research Initiative at the University of Wisconsin Law School."

"We kick off the show with Bryna Godar, a Staff Attorney with UW's State Democracy Research Initiative. We are talking about the next steps for Minnesota in their pursuit of a lawsuit against the ICE Agent who killed a Minneapolis citizen in her car last week. She discusses the process, as well as the hurdles of mounting a case against the Federal government in any situation let alone the current administration."

"Federal courts have sometimes blocked state prosecutions under that provision, out of concern that state authorities are using their prosecutorial power to frustrate the federal government from legitimately exercising its own powers, according to Bryna Godar, a staff attorney at the University of Wisconsin Law School's State Democracy Research Initiative."

"Protestors rallied statewide over the weekend condemning Immigration and Customs Enforcement and honoring the Minnesota resident fatally shot by an ICE agent Wednesday. A reporter details Milwaukee protests, an Appleton demonstrator shares his perspective and an attorney provides legal analysis."

"'Federal officers do not have absolute immunity for actions taken on the job but they do have some immunities,' said Bryna Godar, a staff attorney at the State Democracy Research Initiative at the University of Wisconsin Law School."